A bulging disc spreads out a little along a wide stretch of the disc's edge. A herniated disc is a word people use for that and for something very different, a disc extrusion, where a crack in the tough outer ring lets some of the soft center push out in one spot. That mix-up is why Dr. Strother talks about a disc bulge versus a disc extrusion.
Here is the key point. The word on your report describes the shape of a disc. It does not tell you how much it hurts, how serious it is, or what to do next. That answer comes from matching the picture to your symptoms and your exam.
Below, Dr. Strother explains the words that matter, what the research says, and how we sort it out at Corrective Chiropractic in New Buffalo.
What is a spinal disc?
Discs are the cushions between the bones of your spine, the vertebrae. Each one has a tough outer ring wrapped around a softer center. They cushion the spine, keep space between the bones, and let you bend and reach.
Discs change with age. Over time they become less flexible, and that wear is where many bulges start.
Why is the word "herniation" so confusing?
Because people use it for two very different things. In 2014, three spine and radiology societies agreed on standard disc terms (Fardon and colleagues). Under those terms, a herniation means a focused push of disc material past its normal edge. A bulge is not a herniation at all. But many reports, websites, and even doctors still call a bulge a "herniated disc."
That is why Dr. Strother skips the umbrella word. He talks about two things: a disc bulge and a disc extrusion. Those two words tell you much more about what is going on.
What is a disc bulge?
A disc bulge spreads past its normal edge over a broad area. Under the 2014 terms, it involves about 25% or more of the disc's outer edge. Mayo Clinic says "at least a quarter to a half" of the edge is usually affected, and only the tough outer layer is involved.
Think of a broad stretch of the disc sagging outward a bit, not something breaking through. The North American Spine Society describes bulges as a product of normal wear and tear, often seen in people with no pain.
What is a disc extrusion?
An extrusion is a type of herniation. Mayo Clinic explains that a herniation starts with a crack in the tough outer layer, which lets some of the softer inner material push out. It covers less than 25% of the disc's edge. MRI reports name two main types:
- Protrusion: the pushed-out material still has a wide base where it joins the disc.
- Extrusion: more material has pushed out, and the part outside is wider than its neck back to the disc.
You may hear a herniation called a ruptured or slipped disc. The whole disc does not slip. Only the area around the crack is involved.
| Disc bulge | Disc extrusion | |
|---|---|---|
| How much of the edge | About 25% or more | A small, focused area |
| What happens | Broad outward spread | Soft inner material pushes out in one spot |
| How it starts | Wear and tear with age | A crack in the tough outer ring |
| Pain | Less likely to cause pain | More likely to irritate a nerve root |
Which one is more likely to cause pain?
A focused herniation, like an extrusion. Mayo Clinic explains that the pushed-out material reaches farther, so it has a better chance of bothering a nerve root. That can happen by pressing on the nerve, but more often it causes painful inflammation of the nerve root.
MedlinePlus describes what that can feel like:
- Lower back: sharp pain in part of the leg, hip, or buttock, numbness in other areas, and sometimes pain or numbness along the back of the calf or the bottom of the foot. That leg may also feel weak.
- Neck: pain when you move your neck, deep pain near the shoulder blade, or pain that travels into the upper arm, forearm, and fingers.
Pain that travels down a leg or arm like this is called radicular pain. When the pain follows the sciatic nerve into the buttock, hip, or leg, it is called sciatica.
Can you have a disc bulge and no pain?
Yes, and it is common. A 2015 review pooled MRI and CT findings from 3,110 people with no symptoms. Disc bulges showed up in 30% of 20-year-olds and 84% of 80-year-olds. Disc protrusions showed up in 29% of 20-year-olds and 43% of 80-year-olds.
The authors said many of these findings are likely part of normal aging. The NHS puts it plainly: many people with a slipped disc will never know they have one.
Can a herniated disc get better?
Often, yes. MedlinePlus says that with a herniated disc, "the pain, numbness, or weakness often goes away or improves a lot over weeks to months."
A 2015 review looked at people with low back disc bulges and herniations who were treated without surgery and scanned at least twice. Some regression, meaning the disc material shrank back, showed up in 70% of extrusions, 41% of protrusions, and 13% of bulging discs. That review measured scans, not pain, so a smaller disc on a later MRI and feeling better are two different things.
How does Dr. Strother evaluate a disc problem?
It starts with a conversation. The $27 consult is time for Dr. Strother to hear what you feel, how it started, and what you have already tried. Bring your MRI or older X-rays. He goes through them with you.
Testing is a shared decision. If more testing makes sense, he tells you why, and you decide together. That is test, not guess. Our office has a brand-new, high-frequency, high-tech X-ray on site. It checks bone structure, alignment, and rotation, the height of the bones and of the disc spaces, and arthritic changes in and around the spine, called spondylosis. It also helps judge how much narrowing, or stenosis, can be seen from the bones. An X-ray does not show the disc itself. The MRI does, so the two are read together with your exam.
Then he checks how your body works. Dr. Strother looks at spinal biomechanics and neurologic function, including strength.
Weakness or numbness changes the plan. If you have weakness or numbness in an arm or leg, Dr. Strother is very guarded. He always gets a surgical consult to see whether you need a surgical opinion. Some patients come to him the other way around: they have already seen a surgeon, were given the option of conservative care, and want to explore it.
What about spinal decompression?
In Dr. Strother's words, "spinal decompression traction has been a game changer for our patients for over fifteen years." Before any treatment plan, he reviews all of your tests, including any MRI you have, and checks your spinal biomechanics and neurologic function, including strength. That is how he decides if you are a good candidate.
Many people who are worried about surgery see decompression as a way to work on their health and wellbeing without jumping straight to a more invasive procedure. It is not right for everyone, and it is not a promise that you will avoid surgery. Individual results vary. An evaluation determines whether care may be appropriate.
Still trying to make sense of your MRI?
Patients come to us from New Buffalo, the rest of Harbor Country, and nearby Michigan City, Indiana. Find us at 400 S Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117, at the corner of S Whittaker St and Clay St. Hours are Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday, 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.; Tuesday, 2:30 to 6 p.m.; and Saturday, 8 to 11:30 a.m. We are closed Friday and Sunday.
Bring your MRI report and book the $27 consult, or call or text (269) 469-1310. For more, see our disc bulge evaluation page, or read whether a chiropractor can make spinal stenosis worse.
Sources
- Mayo Clinic: Bulging disk vs. herniated disk: What's the difference? (May 2026)
- North American Spine Society (KnowYourBack.org): What is the difference between a disc bulge and a herniation? (updated Dec 2016)
- Fardon DF, et al. Lumbar disc nomenclature: version 2.0. Recommendations of the combined task forces of NASS, ASSR and ASNR. Spine J. 2014
- Brinjikji W, et al. Systematic literature review of imaging features of spinal degeneration in asymptomatic populations. AJNR. 2015
- Chiu CC, et al. The probability of spontaneous regression of lumbar herniated disc: a systematic review. Clin Rehabil. 2015
- MedlinePlus (NLM) Medical Encyclopedia: Herniated disk (reviewed Aug 2024)
- NHS: Slipped disc (reviewed April 2024)
- NHS: Back pain (reviewed March 2026)
Frequently asked questions
What do bulge, extrusion, and herniation mean?
These are the standard terms from the 2014 spine and radiology nomenclature (Fardon and colleagues). A disc bulge is a broad, shallow spread of the disc past its normal edge, covering about a quarter or more of the edge. A disc extrusion is a focused push of disc material where the part that pushed out is wider than its neck back to the disc. Herniation is the umbrella word for any focused push of disc material past its edge, which includes protrusions and extrusions. In everyday talk, people also call a bulge a herniation, which is why the word confuses so many patients.
Is a slipped disc the same as a bulging disc?
Not by the standard definitions. "Slipped disc" and "ruptured disc" are everyday names for a herniated disc, and the whole disc does not actually slip. Some health pages use these words loosely, so ask what your own report says and what it means for you.
Which is worse, a bulging disc or a herniated disc?
A focused herniation, like an extrusion, is more likely to cause pain. The material that pushes out reaches farther, so it has a better chance of irritating a nerve root. Still, neither word measures how bad your pain is. These terms describe the shape of the disc, not your pain or how severe your case is.
Can a herniated disc get better on its own?
Often, yes, without surgery. MedlinePlus says the symptoms of a herniated disc frequently fade or get much better within weeks to months. In a 2015 review of people with low back disc problems who were treated without surgery and scanned again later, 70% of extrusions, 41% of protrusions, and 13% of bulging discs showed some regression, meaning the disc material had shrunk back. A smaller disc on a scan is not the same thing as feeling better.
Does an X-ray show a herniated disc?
No. An X-ray does not show the disc itself. An MRI does. A spine X-ray shows bone structure, alignment, rotation, the height of the bones and the space between them, and arthritic changes, and it can give a sense of how much narrowing (stenosis) there may be. Those findings are read together with your exam and any MRI you bring. At Corrective, any testing is decided together after the consult. Test, not guess.
This article is general information, not medical advice. It doesn't replace an exam by a chiropractor or medical doctor. If you have a medical emergency, call 911.